Skip to main content

The Great Halloween Controversy (& Why It Matters for Christian Homeschoolers)

 



A few days ago, while I was out running errands, I saw a house (in a fairly nice neighborhood) with seasonal (read that: Halloween themed) "decorations" in their yard. 


... Okay, before I even get going with this post, I have to hit "pause" & state for the record that the word "decorations" feels wrong when what I saw was a means of glorifying death & very macabre ...


As a mom of five now adult children who homeschooled for 25 years, every now and again I get a bit reflective and do a "rear-view mirror cross-examination" of things we did in our family that I would do differently if given the chance. One of those things is the way we "celebrated" Halloween. 


We did all the things. Went to the pumpkin patch, did the corn mazes, carved the pumpkins, decorated the house with "creepy" things, let the kids pick (or design and create) their costumes, attended harvest parties, church events (and hosted a lot of church events when my husband and I led a youth group for over a decade), went door-to-door and/or to trunk-or-treat events on the 31st of October. I feel like we did it all for the entirety of their childhood years...and I honestly do not for the life of me know why I didn't question my mindless participation in the whole doggone thing. 


Sure, there were things that were off limits for us. The super demonic type of stuff, the horror movies (huge absolute no for us on those), the clearly dark side with a heavy emphasis on the evil and the Satanic...all of those were never part of our family life. But there were things that niggled at me, and I let them slide. Or maybe I pushed the niggling feeling aside, more than let them slide. I don't think my concerns would have dissipated had I not been their primary "dissipator", if you know what I mean. 


And there were plenty of things that did not sit well with me, but I simply had to ignore in order to let my kids participate in all the Halloween stuff. Things like headstones and skeletons. As someone who experienced tragic, sudden, unexpected and somewhat horrific losses of close family members in my teens, I was never comfortable with headstones used as "decorations". Corpses don't tend to spark joy for people who've suffered traumatic loss in their formative years. Headstones have never represented "fun" to me; rather, a headstone represents the space in a cemetery where I first felt overwhelmingly uncertain of how to move forward, unable to reconcile the fact that the world kept spinning, people kept doing all their normal daily stuff, and I did not know how to deal with leaving my loved one buried in the cold ground when the funeral was over. Headstones mark the place where death lies, literally. For lots of people, many of them children, the headstone is a stark and painful reminder of loved ones that will never again speak to you, hug you, come to Thanksgiving dinner, be part of your wedding day...


My father died in a horrific way when I was fifteen. Almost exactly one year earlier, I lost a family member who had not even reached the preschool years. I was extremely close to this little one who died in a car accident on an icy winter road, and this event changed me permanently. I clearly remember the me "before" and the me "after". When my dad died 11 1/2 months later, I changed again. The Bible refers to us as the clay and God as the Potter, and in Jeremiah 18:4 uses the phrase, "And He made it again another..." in describing the way God is in charge of making His vessels what He wants them to be. On the flip side of this beautiful remaking that God does, I experienced a remaking at age 14 and then at 15 which was dark and ugly and hardened parts of me that have never again fully softened. Grief and loss do that, don't they? So why do we fail to consider this come October, when the stuff we put in our front lawns is on full display for every child to see when they step outside? And why didn't I opt out of this icky holiday when I was raising my own children?

I guess I just got stuck going with the flow and didn't want to deal with the things that bothered me about the holiday. So, I kept it as "clean" and un-demonic as I could while allowing my children to have some fun. But it isn't just fun, and you can't clean up Satan's grime. And is it possible to even really keep your own family safe from the evil aspects of Halloween while simultaneously participating in other aspects of it? 

I'm sharing all of this here on my blog because I hope it will encourage you to make the hard right decisions for your own family rather than going with the flow like I did for so many years. And I also hope it will land in front of someone who has never considered that tombstones and skeletons represent the worst moment of their lives for so many children and adults. We can't not see this stuff; it's all over, and every time we get in our car to run errands, we see it. Some of us have had enough death in our lives, and we don't ever want to see it celebrated again. 

I think this has become a much more controversial subject in the last five or ten years because the next generation of Christian parents, and specifically Christian homeschoolers as it relates to this blog, have come out much more boldly and vocally in opposition to the dark side of Halloween. I agree with them. I applaud them. I am thankful they are speaking out. And I am sorry Gen X parents did not do better by our own children. 

Halloween matters for Christians, and I am not going to encourage you to go down a rabbit hole and look into everything that takes places on the 31st, and all throughout the month of October. But I will encourage you to pray about this, asking the Lord to lead your family in the way He wants you to go. Ask Him, listen for His answer, and then simply do what He tells you. It might make you "controversial" to other people in your neighborhood, but when we follow Jesus, we are controversial people anyway, so I suppose this is just one more way that we are standing out, letting our light shine before men, living in this world but not being of it. 

And if you happen to know a child who has lost a loved one, would you pray for them this month? Ask God to keep them from seeing things that remind them of their loss and to comfort them as they grieve. Your prayers make a difference!

As always, Lord bless you and happy homeschooling!



Comments

Popular Posts

A Homeschool Mom's Devotional by award-winning podcaster Jan L. Burt

Colossians 4:17 tells the reader to "be sure to carry out the work the Lord gave you". How can this be applied to the enormously busy lifestyle of a homeschool mom? First of all, we must always remember that the Word of God has the answer for our every need and we can trust fully in God to use His Word to lead us, guide us, correct us, and bless us. Keeping that in mind, let's consider what this verse is saying. We are told to carry out, or complete, the work the Lord has given us. We are wives, mothers, homeschoolers. Those three BIG job descriptions come immediately to mind when I think of homeschooling mothers. Applying God's Word to our life means carrying out our work as wives, as mothers, and as homeschoolers. When I am exhausted from another long day (or long week, long month, long year, etc.) I still must honor the Lord by blessing my husband. Maybe that means having a hot meal on the table when he arrives home from work. Perhaps your husband...

I Gotta Let You Know Two Very Important Things (Seriously, They Are Truly Important For You To Know...)

 First, a big --- fat --- hefty dose of encouragement for you, my wonderful homeschooling friend.  As you get ready to roll into the fall of 2020...stop for just one moment and hear what God's Word has to say to you right here, right now, on the brink of the last stretch of what has possibly been the most turn-your-whole-world-upside-down year ever.  Psalm 125:2 - As the mountains surround Jerusalem, so the Lord surrounds His people both now and forevermore.   You are surrounded.  Completely & totally, that's exactly how surrounded you are.  Going into the great unknown as, say, a working mom whose children are going to be doing school online at home (or a working mom homeschooling and working from home for just the next several months, but not planning on continuing to home educate after things "normalize" again).  This is God's promise just for you as you embark upon this season of life. I really, truly believe He wants you to know that He has yo...

Schoolhouse Review Crew ~ A Thomas Jefferson Education (This Week in History)

Rachel DeMille, of Thomas Jefferson Education , promotes a fascinating educational philosophy (based on The Seven Keys of Great Teaching ). Her website, www.TJEd.org , provides a thorough explanation of this philosophy. It's also an excellent history resource that I hope my blog readers will consider using in their homeschools. I really love what Rachel is doing! I am not reviewing everything available at the website - trust me, there is quite a bit to be found there! What I am reviewing is " This Week in History ", a resource that covers a wide variety of subjects and topics on a daily basis in an engaging and interesting manner. I have used this as a part of our history curriculum, but it really is so much more than history.  Each week I receive an email with the current week's " This Week in History ". I am also able to access this information at the website, along an archive that covers the current year. And I also receive daily emails, called ...

My Preferred Bible Reading Plan

We all know that reading our Bibles is a key part of living a healthy life as a follower of Jesus. But busy homeschool moms may, at times, struggle to know what part of the Bible to read on any given day. Some people read the Bible through, Genesis to Revelation, and when they finish simply start over. Others have reading plans that follow along with the sermons their pastor is currently preaching. And yet others find themselves "stuck in the Psalms", since they're not quite sure what to read. I'm not going to tell you how many chapters a day you should read, or that you need to do exactly what I do. I'm just going to share what has worked for me, and hopefully encourage you to get into the Word using some type of plan ~ because every homeschool mom knows what happens to our plans when we fail to create a plan, right?! I use a prayer and Bible reading guide called "Prayer Point" , published by Samaritan's Purse. About every 8 weeks, I receive a...

Do You Homeschool? Then You Need to Read This Article!

Whether you have been homeschooling for a month, a year, or a decade, you've inevitably faced the "questions". Questions about socialization, college, athletics, driver's ed, high-school biology, etc. etc. etc. and so on..... It seems as if homeschoolers are ripe for questions from day one; but the flip side seems to be that there really is no flip side. We are expected to patiently answer any and all questions, smiling politely and pretending we've never heard this line of questioning before. But when we try to ask a few questions about, say, public schools as a whole or the issue of private schools being used as a last-ditch landing spot for students expelled from public school, well...ahem...we're pretty much told to keep quiet. No one wants to hear our questions, and often times no one really wants to hear our answers to their questions. They just kind of want us to....go....away. I'm not planning on going away any time soon. And neither are my fiv...